Tastyworks vs City Index

Tastyworks or City Index – which is better for UK traders 2025? Compare Tastyworks and City Index in this detailed breakdown of their platforms, features and fees.

Tastyworks vs City Index Comparison Table 2025
Tastyworks City Index
rating empty
rating full
3
rating empty
rating full
4.4
Tastyworks is ranked #111 among UK brokers. City Index is ranked #18 among CFD brokers.
Review
Review
tastytrade is an award-winning brokerage, launched in 2017. The brand specializes in futures, options and stock trading with US and Australian regulatory oversight. The proprietary trading interface, designed by the creators of Thinkorswim, is powerful with plenty of integrated tools to suit active traders. Established in 1983 and now a part of the Nasdaq-listed StoneX Group, City Index is a renowned and award-winning broker specializing in forex, CFDs, and spread betting. Offering over 13,500 instruments, an evolving Web Trader platform, top-tier educational resources, and 24/5 customer support, City Index delivers a comprehensive trading experience.
CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 69% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.
Pros
  • Transparent pricing model including a $1 commission on stocks and ETF options, with maximum limits per leg for some assets
  • Wide range of asset classes including options, futures, stocks, ETFs and indices with the majority available to trade 24/5
  • Good choice of account types suitable for various investment goals including IRAs and individual/joint trading accounts
  • Powerful proprietary platform with detailed insights, real-time trading videos, and order adjustment features
  • Excellent regulatory oversight from FINRA, NFA and ASIC with SIPC insurance for US clients
  • City Index is regulated by top-tier authorities like the FCA (UK), ASIC (Australia), and MAS (Singapore), while its ownership by StoneX Group Inc., a listed company, further reinforces its credibility.
  • City Index has made strides to enhance the trading experience, notably through its Performance Analytics in 2024 for insights into trades and discipline, plus an upgraded mobile app featuring in-built market research and news at a swipe.
  • City Index boasts 13,500+ markets spanning forex, indices, shares, commodities, bonds, ETFs, and interest rates, with the platform's inclusion of niche markets like interest rates offering unique trading avenues not always found elsewhere.
  • City Index provides versatile trading platforms for all skill levels. The intuitive Web Trader platform is ideal for beginners, while support for MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and TradingView adds robust analysis and automation features, ensuring a flexible experience for traders of all levels.
Cons
  • Less suitable for beginners with no demo account and basic educational resources
  • Narrow range of instruments with no forex trading
  • No credit/debit card payments
  • USD base currency only
  • No 529 plan
  • While many brokers like eToro have expanded their crypto offerings, City Index only provides crypto CFDs, and the limited range may not satisfy traders looking for a broader selection of altcoins.
  • Unlike brokers such as AvaTrade and BlackBull, City Index does not provide passive investment opportunities like social copy trading, or real stock or ETF ownership, making it less appealing for hands-off trading.
  • City Index lacks an Islamic account with swap-free trading conditions, making the broker less appealing to Muslim traders compared to providers like Eightcap and Pepperstone.
Awards
  • Best CFD Provider 2024 - ADVFN International Financial Awards
  • Best Trading Platform 2022 - Online Money Awards
FCA Regulated
No

List of FCA Regulated Brokers

Yes
Instruments
Stocks, ETFs, Cryptos, Futures, Options CFDs, Forex, Stocks, Indices, Commodities, Crypto, Futures, Options, Bonds, Interest Rates,ETFs,Spread Betting
Demo Account
No Yes
Minimum Deposit
$0 $0
Payment Methods
Minimum Trade
0.01 Lots
Regulator
SEC, FINRA FCA, ASIC, CySEC, MAS
Mobile Apps
iOS & Android iOS & Android
Trading App

The City Index app offers a user-friendly mobile trading experience with bespoke features like one-swipe trading. What’s also neat is the full-screen TradingView charts with 60+ technical indicators to plan your next move, while you can stay ahead with real-time price alerts and notifications. Additionally, Performance Analytics tools, added in 2024, provide insights into your trading metrics, helping you refine your trading strategies.
iOS App Rating
rating empty
rating empty
rating full
3.8
Android App Rating
rating empty
rating empty
rating full
3.1
Margin Trading
Yes No
Margin Rate
2.5%
MetaTrader 4
No Yes
MetaTrader 5
No No
cTrader
No No
AlgoTrader
No No
OmniTrader
No No
TradingView
No Yes
Autochartist
No No
eSignal
No No
Trading Central
No Yes
STP Account
No No
ECN Account
No No
DMA Account
No No
MAM Account
No No
PAMM Account
No No
LAMM Account
No No
Demat Account
No No
AI / Machine Learning
No Yes
Robo Advisor
No No
Negative Balance Protection
No Yes
Market Maker
No Yes
P2P Trading
No No
Spot Trading
No Yes
Auto Trading
Expert Advisors (EAs) on MetaTrader
Copy Trading
No No
Social Trading
No No
Trade Signals
SMART Signals
VPS Hosting
No No
Tournaments
No No
Demo Competitions
No No
Ethical Investing
No Yes
Custodial Account
Yes No
Guaranteed Stop Loss
No Yes
Inactivity Fee
£12
Islamic Account
No No
Account Currencies
  • USD
  • EUR
  • GBP
  • AUD
  • PLN
  • CZK
Commodities
  • Gold
  • Oil
  • Silver
  • Copper
  • Livestock
  • Platinum
  • Natural Gas
  • Soybeans
  • Nickel
  • Iron
  • Orange Juice
  • Cannabis
  • Palladium
  • Coffee
  • Cotton
  • Lean Hogs
  • Sugar
  • Wheat
CFD
City Index has one of the most extensive suite of CFDs we’ve seen, providing short-term trading opportunities on diverse assets, sectors and regions. Its ‘Trade Ideas’ also excel for active traders looking for information to inform decisions while the Web Trader boasts extensive charting capabilities with 90+ technical indicators.
Leverage
1:30
FTSE Spread
1.0
GBPUSD Spread<
1.1
Oil Spread
1.5
Stocks Spread
Variable
Forex
City Index is one of the most trusted forex brokers, providing an above-average selection of 80+ currency pairs alongside tight spreads from 0.7 pips, trading alerts, and terrific insights into FX markets, with 99.99% of trades successfully executed.
Assets
84
GBPUSD Spread
1.1
EURUSD Spread
0.8
EURGBP Spread
1.0
Currency Indices
  • USD
Cryptocurrency
tastytrade offers a small selection of cryptocurrencies, available to trade as long positions only. This includes Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin and Dogecoin. But with a narrow suite of digital currencies, it isn't the best pick for high-volume crypto traders. City Index offers a modest handful of crypto CFDs, including Bitcoin, Ethereum and Ripple. But where it stands out is its in-house market insights and news coverage of major market moves, alongside its intuitive web platform.
Spread
Variable 0.5% (BTC)
Coins
  • BTC
  • ETH
  • LTC
  • DOGE
  • BTC
  • BCH
  • ETH
  • LTC
  • XRP
Crypto Lending
No No
Crypto Mining
No No
Crypto Staking
No No
Auto Market Maker
No No
Tastyworks City Index
Review
Review
CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 69% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.
More Comparisons
Tastyworks
vs

 City Index
vs